Play it again sports Carmel
Open
10:00 am - 7:00 pm

9 reviews

ipohl07

@ipohl07

The worst disc golf store in Indianapolis. The staff is rude and their hiring. But I have sold discs to them in them in the past. For over $200 for 20 premium discs but now they are only willing to pay $41. Talk about cheap.Also all the discs are either from prodigy or other cheap stores. Don’t go if you are trying to sell your discs only go if you want cheap branded prodigy discs.

reesehoffer17

@reesehoffer17

Great selection of new and used discs. They get regular shipments of newly released discs. Owner/manager is a great guy.

toastydan

@toastydan

Great selection from all of the major manufacturers.

isamoor

@isamoor

Owners and employees are very nice. They keep a scale behind the counter you can borrow. Usually have a couple hundred used discs that rotate pretty quickly. There are five solid courses nearby along the White River so that helps rotate the used inventory. And they do keep a few hundred new discs in stock as well. Most of the main manufacturers are represented.

eskeet

@eskeet

Had a bunch of buckets of used and new discs. Lots to choose from, good prices on the new discs as well

gansonsalmon

@gansonsalmon

Great selection of new AND used discs. My favorite finds are always in the used section. Plus, you can take old discs you don’t want and they will buy them off you for a few bucks or for store credit.

colefenner25

@colefenner25

Found a Ricky Signed Destroyer 10 bucks!!!!

jamesar23

@jamesar23

Surprisingly good selection for a PiAS. Gotten several unique finds off their used selection. Often well-stocked and with a decent selection. A larger selection of gateway than most places

ddownham

@ddownham

Have a pretty solid selection of discs and regularly updated. Stop in every couple weeks and this location will have a ton of new and used discs in since the last time. Have found a few gems!